The great Arab-Muslim philosopher Al Ghazali once said “Ecstasy means the state that comes from listening to music.” However, it has recently become more of a mediocrity that would probably make Al Ghazali roll over in his grave.
Mediocrity in music waters down the complexity of what once made Arabic music so great and lowers listeners’ standards with respect to quality.
It is rare to find a piece of Arabic music that is truly a work of art. It is overwhelmingly some variation of the words “habibi”, “layali”, “ayuni”, “albi” recorded to a generic track of music that may have been used by other artists, maybe even many times over. It is a track we are all too familiar with: a dramatic orchestra with violins and tableh being played with a choir repeating everything the singer says at least twice-over. The unoriginality and repetitiveness of this music can be likened to dancing the traditional Arabic debke, a group dance popular in the Levantine where people hold hands in a circle and dance round and round to the same foot movements of one, two steps, kick. The person at the head of the line shows off his moves and style in his dance, and then the second and third people try to imitate him while the fourth person struggles with his one, two steps, kick. But still they go on doing it for hours and hours.
Arab society is one that is deeply rooted in culture, tradition, and religion and has generally been resistant to change and foreign influence and this especially applies to art and what society perceives as acceptable and what excites its members.
The artists all follow each other, and it is becoming increasingly difficult to distinguish between them. There are several channels on television dedicated to music videos, showing many scantily-clad Arab women doing more moaning than singing while writhing around in unbelievable amounts of makeup. Male artists, by humorous contrast, are often shown having a very average physique, often balding and dressed up extravagantly and strutting around in Casanova poses. Sexism is an unavoidable truth, with the nature of any song differing greatly from male to female singer.
The infamous song, “Jamhuriyet Albi” (The Republic of My Heart) by Lebanese singer Mohammad Iskandar was the subject of controversy at the time of its release in 2010. With lyrics like “My heart beats for you but we have no girls here that work with their degrees, our girls are pampered and everything she wants is available”, and “Why cause yourself problems? Assuming I agree that you work, what would we do about your beauty?”, many thought it undermined women’s rights and intelligence. Syrian women’s rights group Mrsaad Nisaa Syria (Syrian Women’s Monitor) even called on radio stations to ban the songs (to no avail), deeming it “an open call to abolish education for women and a flagrant invitation for violence against women”.
One could argue that pop music is the same in any country in terms of song choice and types of performers, but there is also a severe misinterpretation. While learning about pop culture from other countries should always be encouraged in order to evolve, we are forgetting that big Western pop stars also have very high standards. It is well known throughout the Arab World that very few artists are actually involved in the song writing process in any way. Even the biggest names in Arabic music today do not write their own lyrics as they rely instead on paid lyricists, a widely overlooked practice in the Arab world.
However overrated most high profile Western pop stars are, there is no denying that they do have the whole basic package for which they have worked hard for, (a voice, beauty, dance moves, artistic ability, charisma, etc..) a package that most Arab pop stars lack. We meanwhile have imported many live music based programs from the West into our Arab media namely Arab Idol, The Voice and Arab’s Got Talent to name a few. Are these new shows a way to promote born-talent and art in the Arab world? Or are these fixed 2-5 minute performance shows merely another superficial import that would further skew our view of art and our capabilities? Only time will tell.
Arabic music had what is now called a “golden age” between the 1920’s and 1950’s where artists like Oum Kalthoum, Farid al Atrash, Abdel Halim Hafez and the recently deceased Wadi’ Al-Safi were considered the greats. Although most singers from this age are long gone now, families of three different generations can still be found gathered behind a television watching gritty black and white live concert performances to a crowd of men and women (none of whom are veiled) cheering and clapping while the older family members sing along and tell stories of simpler times. It is not at all unusual to find an Arab teenager with at least a few songs from this age memorized or on their mp3 players, although the equivalent of this in American society, like a 15 year old with Elvis Presley or Frank Sinatra would definitely be strange. This “interestingly signals a possible subconscious feeling that there is yet satisfaction left unattained from modern music”, as Dr. Jason Rentfrow of the American Psychological Association claims. Simply, if you don’t find what you are looking for after digging in your sandbox, you will look elsewhere.
There are many underrated artists in the Arab world that are doing revolutionary things with traditional forms of Arabic music. As different as they may appear on the surface, they all share a common goal of metamorphosing music and culture as we know it. Take a look at a few of the trailblazers:
Kulna Sawa
Kulna Sawa means “all of us together”, an appropriate name for this ensemble of 11 musicians. In 1994, the group found their signature sound when they began re-arranging several Arabic folkloric songs, and re-producing them in a contemporary style to make them more attractive to a young generation that had forgotten or been unexposed to its true musical heritage. Members use an interesting variety of instruments including a saxophone, oud, piano, and trumpet, in itself a symbol of diversity Kulna Sawa itself has as a mixture of Syrians from different parts of the country and of both Muslim and Christian faith. This fact combined with its powerfully catchy and reminiscent folk music appealing to people of all religious and cultural backgrounds has won the group 2 peace awards from the United Nations and a strong international fanbase.
Mashrou’ Leila
This Lebanese indie-rock band emerged on the scene in 2008 and is made up of 7 alumni of the American University of Beirut. With their unabashed and unapologetic lyrics on politics, sexuality, and society, this band has taken the Arab world and beyond by storm. Lead singer Hamed Sinno sings these often satirical lyrics to the tune of a distinctive but genre less blend of Arabic tarab, folk, rock and electro. On the bands genres of music Sinno says, “At this point in time in Arabic music I think we unfortunately have a set law of mainstream music, so when people say we make alternative music it just means that we are not following what everyone else does.” Sinno is also arguably the first openly gay performer in the Middle East which has not been taken lightly. After an appearance on Egyptian satirist Bassem Yousef’s “Al Bernameg”, critics were in uproar and demanded that both Sinno and Yousef be arrested for promoting homosexuality. A few fan favorites of Mashrou Leila songs are “Fasateen”, “Raksit Leila”, and “Imm il Jacket”.
Rachid Taha
Rachid Taha is an Algerian artist who combines the country’s unique raï music style with rock and electronic influences to create a sound of his own. His gritty, raspy voice singing in frustration and agony combined with his special blend of ‘Rock n’ Raï’ has made Taha a revolutionary figure in Algeria and abroad. There isn’t a topic Taha hasn’t handled in his music, nor an instrument left to be unused which has made him garner rave reviews from many high profile critics in his 33 years as a performer.